Ask "Mr. Music"
Jerry Osborne

In syndication since 1986, and now in our 32nd year — Over 3,200 questions answered
Most recent column here — plus 20 years of archived ones linked below


DEAR JERRY: As I browse the albums at our local record shows, I rarely find LPs by artists with only one big hit. One that I never find for sale is Cathy Jean and the Roommates, of "Please Love Me Forever" fame. Since it's listed in your "Rockin' Records" guide, I assume it does exist. Before writing you, I checked eBay and there isn't a single copy of that LP, in any condition.
—Bill Kennedy, New Haven, Conn.

DEAR BILL: Not just one, but two versions exist of the 1961 LP by Cathy Jean and the Roomates, occasionally shown as "Roommates" on their singles. The first issue is Valmor #78. It has a plain white cover with black print. There is no photo of Cathy Jean and the Roommates, who had not yet become well known. Not only that, but the LP title "Great Oldies" is at the top in bigger and bolder type. Below that is the list of the 12 songs, followed by "...with Cathy Jean and the Roomates."

By February of 1961, one of the songs on the LP, "Please Love Me Forever," as a single began climbing the charts on its way to the nation's Top 10.

Valmor then came up with a somewhat improved cover, with poor quality color photos, one of Cathy Jean and another of the Roommates. They also changed their catalog number from #78 to #789. Valmor also gave it this new, yet weird, title: "At the Hop! ...with Cathy Jean and the Roomates."

I say weird, since "At the Hop" is not one of the tracks on the LP, and "Please Love Me Forever," their Top 10 hit, is the first cut. Wouldn't it have been more appropriate to title the LP "Please Love Me Forever ...with Cathy Jean and the Roomates."

Both issues have the same contents, with Cathy Jean on side one, and the Roomates on side two. Near-mint copies of either issue sell in the $450 $550 range.

Join our spam-free e-mail group and once or twice a year, when we have a new book or product we think might be of interest, we'll mail you a notification. We will NEVER share your information with anyone!
Simply click here to send us a note with your name and e-mail address.

New column usually appears on Monday. Bookmark this page and visit at least once each week!

Use these direct links to connect with Jerry on Facebook or Twitter:

Jerry Osborne: Background and Publishing History

2018 columns

January 1 January 8 January 15 January 22 January 29
February 5 February 12 February 19 February 26
March 5 March 12 March 19 March 26
April 2 April 9 April 16 April 23 April 30
May 7 May 14 May 21 May 28
June 4 June 11 June 18 June 26
July 2 July 9 July 16 July 23 July 30
August 6 August 13 August 20 August 27
September 3 September 10 September 17 September 24
October 1 October 8

For another 1,040 weeks worth of fun and informative reading, dig into the Mr. Music Archives!
1998 1999 2001 2002
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017


Quick Jump! Select a site from menu below and we'll transport you directly there.

Return to Osborne Enterprises Home Page

Includes some sample tracks from the "Lost and Found" VINYL LP!

General Correspondence e-mail